AAR 1
From: Nigel Marsh, chief tactical umpire
I was able to combine all the individual orders of battle into one 'grand' OoB, with the following results (a more detailed set of casualty statistics is also available):
Pyhrric Victory for the Grande Armee
The Grande Armee has suffered losses of:
| | [ 28%] | 33931 | men of all arms |
| incl. | [ 5%] | 6605 | prisoners of all arms |
| | | 5 | standard[s] lost |
| | | 112 | cannon[s] lost |
| Honors: | [193] 2/108me Ligne |
| |
| | [ 30%] | 24826 | bayonets |
| | [ 27%] | 7038 | sabres |
| | [ 17%] | 2067 | artillerists |
The Russian Army has suffered losses of:
| | [ 30%] | 33331 | men of all arms |
| incl. | [ 8%] | 9181 | prisoners of all arms |
| | | 9 | standard[s] lost |
| | | 200 | cannon[s] lost |
| Honors: | [658] CP Dennisov #5 |
| |
| | [ 30%] | 21572 | bayonets |
| | [ 33%] | 7441 | sabres |
| | [ 27%] | 4318 | artillerists |
Interestingly the casualties are only 600 men in difference in favor of the French. However, the French suffered more dead and wounded, when you subtract the numbers of missing and prisoners.
It is interesting to see that the 'computer' also favored Ahmet as the most feared Russian player - I believe he was commanding [658] CP Dennisov #5. Whilst the French armies most 'valiant' unit belonged to Dessaix's division of I Corps.
I also noted that Imperial Aide Mouton, Comte de Lobau was severely wounded, which increases the French officer casualties to 18 total.
[Nigel had a chance to review some of the post battle casualties, and
thought
these pieces of info would be of interest:]
Russian Officer Casualties [25 Total]
Utitsa
[518] Tehoubarov - mortally wounded
[521] Walewacz - mortally wounded
[512] Eugene of Wurttemberg - severely wounded
[513] Pyshnitskoi - severely wounded
[516] Pillar - severely wounded
[561] Skalon - severely wounded
[608] Kretov - severely wounded
[611] Chatilov - severely wounded
[509] Gluchov - severely wounded
[558] Davydov - lightly wounded
[603] Litovich - lightly wounded
[609] Duka - lightly wounded
[519] Tuchkov II - captured
Flechettes
[524] Tchoglokov - lightly wounded
[531] Goulewicz - lightly wounded
[545] Balem - lightly wounded
[527] Cotliarev - captured
Redoubt
[599] Stepanov - mortally wounded
[620] Miloradovitch - severely wounded - Wing Commander
[596] Tuchkov III - lightly wounded
[556] Tchernich - lightly wounded
Borodino
[577] Rylieff - severely wounded
[578] Pantzerbieter - severely wounded
[583] Gogel - lightly wounded
[588] Woiekov - lightly wounded
French Officer Casualties [17 Total]
Utitsa
[212] DeJean - mortally wounded
[209] Quenot - severely wounded
[211] Reynaud - lightly wounded
[228] Chastel - lightly wounded
Flechettes
[171] Plauzonne - lightly wounded
[172] Broussier - lightly wounded
Redoubt
[192] Alix - mortally wounded
[241] Danloup-Verdun - mortally wounded
[195] Wickenberg - lightly wounded
[238] Lorge - lightly wounded
[240] von Lepel - lightly wounded
[189] Tyskiwicz - captured
Borodino
[159] von Koch - mortally wounded
[156] D'Henin - severely wounded
[158] von Hugel - lightly wounded
[157] Marchand - captured
[218] Subervie - captured
Russian Standards and Eagles Lost [9 Total]
Utitsa
[531] 2/IR Riazan
[765] 1/GR Kiev
[767] 1/GR Moscow
Flechettes
[560] 1/IR Rilsk
[606] 2/IR Sofia
[618] 1/IR Tomsk [Both Standards]
Redoubt
[728] 1/GR Tauride
Borodino
[781] CP 3rd Bug
French Standards and Eagles Lost [6 Total]
Utitsa
[181] 3/12me Ligne
[349] 6me Cuirassiers
Redoubt
[318] 1/2nd Westphalian
[401] 2/5me Westphalian
[300] 2/15th Polish
[311] 12th Polish Lancers
Artillery Material Lost [254 Total]
Russian
Utitsa 147
Flechettes 72
Redoubt 21
Borodino 14
French [113 Total - mostly battalion pieces]
Utitsa 10
Flechettes 14
Redoubt 79
Borodino 10
|
